Tweet
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
Oooooooooooh myyyyyyyyy...YES! 'Nuff said! 
Originally posted by Pomai
-
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
Far be it from me to tell you your wrong, Maddie!!! AAMOF...I completely agree with you. It's a brilliant concept; a great formula. It's a show one either loves or hates. For many it's a show they love to hate. But they just keep watching! It's entertaining and people love to be entertained. The show is making a bundle. And that is, after all, what it's all about. I'd love to know what it costs to air a 30 second commercial. Plenty, I bet!Originally posted by MadAzzaComment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My Synopsis of 2/21/06 episode: 12 Women Sound off
Madisa - Great Performance! as good as a Professional 10/10
Kellie Pickler - Good Performance, Country type singer 9/10
Becky O'Donohue - SO-SO Performance, Off key at times, Octive too low. 7/10
Ayla Brown - Great Vocals, Needs to project the lower tones better 8/10
Paris Bennett - Excellent Performance, Puts lots of feeling into the music 9/10
Stevie Scott - OK Vocals, Not an attention grabber 7/10
Brenna Grethers - OK Vocals, a little boring 7/10
Heather Cox - A little flat 6/10
Melissa McGhee - Pitchy but good strong performance 7/10
Lisa Tucker - Strong Vocals, Good Range 8.5/10
Kinnik Sky - Strong Vocals, Great Range 9/10
Katherine McPhee - Good Vocals, Strong Singer 9/10Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My Synopsis of American Idol Top 12 Men Sound Off 2/22/06
Patrick Hall - Good Vocals 9/10
David Radford - Didn't really show his ability 8/10
Bucky Covington - Good Performance 8/10
Will Makar - Straining too much 7/10
Jose "Sway" Penala - Solid Performance 9/10
Chris Daughtry - Very Good Singer 9/10
Kevin Covais - Needed more power 8/10
Gideon McKinney - Good Vocals 9/10
Elliot Yamin - Very Good Singer 9/10
Bobby Bennet - Decent Performance 8/10
Ace Young - Good Voice 9/10
Taylor Hicks - Interesting Performer 9/10Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My favorites from last night were Taylor and Ace.
------
SPOILER for anyone who wants to know tonight's results:
Girls eliminated:
Becky
Stevie
Guys eliminated:
Bobby
Patrick* I would be most content if my children grew up to be the kind of people who think decorating consists mostly of building enough bookshelves. *
- Anna QuindlenComment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My Synopsis of 2/28/06 episode: Top 10 Women Sound off
01 Katherine McPhee - SO-SO Night 8/10
02 Kinnik Sky - Strong Vocals, Great Range 9/10
03 Lisa Tucker - Good Vocals 9/10
04 Melissa McGhee - Boring performance 6/10
05 Heather Cox - Vocals were OK 8/10
06 Brenna Grethers - OK Vocals, boring 7/10
07 Paris Bennett - WOW! Performance 10/10
08 Ayla Brown - Very Good Strong Performance 10/10
09 Kellie Pickler - Decent Performance 9/10
10 Madisa - Another Great Performance! 10/10Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My Synopsis of American Idol Top 10 Men Sound Off 3/1/06
01 Taylor Hicks - Not Bad 9/10
02 Elliot Yamin - OK 9/10
03 Ace Young - Sounded a little off to me 8/10
04 Gideon McKinney - Started off soft, Great ending 9/10
05 Kevin Covais - Needs mo'power 8/10
06 Jose "Sway" Penala - OK Performance 7/10
07 Will Makar - arrgh! 7/10
08 Bucky Covington - Good Performance 8/10
09 David Radford - Dont know what to say 8/10
10 Chris Daughtry - Great Vocals 9/10Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My favorites from last night were Elliot and Chris; I was disappointed with Taylor and Ace; and Will and David did better than last week.
------
SPOILERS below for anyone who wants to know tonight's results:
Girls eliminated:
Brenna
Heather
Guys eliminated:
Sway
David* I would be most content if my children grew up to be the kind of people who think decorating consists mostly of building enough bookshelves. *
- Anna QuindlenComment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
OUCH! I was going to peek but I will wait 2 more hours....Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
Is it true this show is airing three nights a week? I mean, I know it's popular, but that seems to be a pretty sure step towards overstaying its welcome. Reminds me of when "Who Wants to be a Millionaire" was top dog... and ABC killed it by spreading it to several days.
What a great moneymaker, though. Ratings far and above the competition. "Talent" that they get for a song (pun intended), essentially own outright, and get to exploit further when they "win."Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
The boys sing Tuesday, the girls sing Wednesday, and on Thursday the losing girls/boys are eliminated. But later in the season it airs twice weekly, after they winnow the field down a ways.Originally posted by pzarquon
.
ETA: Uh, hello, where's my spoiler text?Last edited by MadAzza; March 2, 2006, 07:24 PM.Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
I think the show has some intensity. It really is hard to figure out its outcome over the few weeks. as a former record producer I use the show to tease my brain if I can spot the talent and who goes on or who loses. I wish Sway could have lasted a bit longer he has a unique voice, If only sang the song the same way he did it on his exit from the show i think that would have kept him in. Tyler Hicks is one I would have never guessed on. Hip-Hop was my arena, so I guess I am opening my eyes a bit.
42 million votes? damn if you could attach a dollar to each vote.....lots of cash. Even a penny!
Whats up dog?
Am I dreaming or is Paula lusting after all the guys?Last edited by speedtek; March 2, 2006, 09:45 PM.Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
Paula does seem to be lusting quite a bit, and I love her outfits. Did you see her last night, with her boobs falling out all over the place? And I think she's high again. I love high Paula so much more than sober Paula. Much more fun!
But I wish people would stop booing everything Simon says. He's only being honest and telling them what they need to hear, but he gets shouted down for offering *constructive* criticism. Stupid audience!Comment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
Paula definitely took one too many happy pills last night. I'm still confused about the pizza and salad comment.* I would be most content if my children grew up to be the kind of people who think decorating consists mostly of building enough bookshelves. *
- Anna QuindlenComment
-
Re: American Idol Season Five (2006)
My Synopsis of 3/07/06 episode: 8 Women Sound off
01 Paris Bennet 7/10 Good Vocals, Beat was too slow
02 Lisa Tucker 10/10 Strong Vocals
03 Melissa McGhee 8/10 t'was OK
04 Kinnik Sky 7/10 Was too way off....the band was off
05 Katherine McPhee 8/10 A bit irritating on the highs
06 Ayla Brown 7/10 She dropped it
07 Mandisa 10/10 She got the groove!
08 Kellie Pickler 8/10 Vocals were OKComment
Comment